Violated Paradise
Director: Marion Gering
Year: 1963
Marion Gering got his start in Hollywood directing star vehicles in the 1930s with marquee names such as Carole Lombard, Tallulah Bankhead and Charles Laughton, including the 1932 version of Madame Butterfly with Sylvia Sydney and Carey Grant. Gering could not match the success of his early films and later had to take work overseas towards the end of his career. One of the films he made during this period was Violated Paradise, an Italian co-production filmed entirely in Japan that has joined the ranks as one of the greatest mondo films of all time.
The film opens in Hokkaido. Tamako (Mine Kazuko) is an innocent maiden living in a remote Ainu village who is very proud that she was "brought up more like a Japanese than an Ainu." She thinks that the ancient ways of her village are primitive and sets out to leave for Tokyo. She stops at Ama Village, home of the Awabi diving girls, and has a short-lived romance with a handsome fisherman whom she calls a "man god" before leaving for the big city. Most of Violated Paradise was shot like a documentary: Mine Kazuko was the only professional actress in the film and she didn't really have to do much more than interact with the people in her surroundings since she didn't have a single line lines of dialog. The filmmakers later dubbed in cheesy English narration by someone named Paulette Girard, who tried to mimic a Japanese woman with laughable results.
The whole tone of the film changes from a G rated Disney fable to an R rated exploitation flick once Tamako arrives in Tokyo. An unseen male narrator named Thomas L, Rowe goes into a very bad Raymond Chandler-meets-Dragnet impersonation that is wickedly entertaining: "Tokyo, crossroads of the east, city of 39 races, 30 styles of cookery, and 56 ways of making love, of 82 basic odors and 80,000 stinks, of 12 kinds of dirt and 34 vices. One of the most fascinating places in the world, Tokyo. Always new and always old, where the paradise that is Japan can and does get violated." Where did they get those statistics? Has the number of stinks and odors changed in the last 40 years? Man, I'd hate to be the one to have to verify that information.
Thomas L. Rowe goes on to say, "In Japan, men divide their women into categories. One: respectable women- delicate, docile, exquisitely tender creatures. Two: those of the profession... Tokyo has at least 80,000 hostesses and geisha. You'll find them between the sewers and the flowers. And very few of them are flowers. The rest are wherever they can drop their mats. Here the real geisha is reduced to a shadow of herself, retaining but one thing in common with a geisha of the arts: the art of lovemaking" (This guy is severely pissed off and disgusted by all vice going on in Tokyo, but it sounds like he's secretly been to every one of the places he rails against.).
The narrator finally shuts up and we're back to the story of Tamako. Seems like our heroine has gotten herself in a bit of trouble. She was so eager to rid herself of the "ancient Ainu ways" that she took a job as an apprentice geisha thinking that pouring sake for drunk salarymen would make her more "Japanese". Well, Miss high and mighty apparently didn't realize she is only an ersatz geisha, one who is expected to perform special services for preferred customers, and playing the samisen aunt one of them. Will Tamako remain a "flower" or will she end up in the "sewer" of filth and vice? The filmmakers didn't seem to care, just as long as it gave them an excuse to show more scenes of topless Awabi diving girls and mixed bathing at an onsen in Atami.
We'll probably never be known whether Violated Paradise was originally intended to be made as a serious documentary or not. It include priceless footage of Ainu customs and ceremonies, which were unseen by most people outside of Japan at the time.
Trivia: Violated Paradise is based on the book, _Meeting With Japan_ by Fosco Mariani, a long out-of-print book published in 1959.